1.0 | Intro
Better News: TBD has a replica of the FCHR/EEOC standard Charge of Discrimination
Features:
✔ Free
✔ Comprehensive
Best News: As of November 1, 2023, the FCHR still accepts CODs by email (Clerk@FCHR.MyFlorida.com; FCHRInfo@FCHR.MyFlorida.com)
- The EEOC, on the other hand, does not accept CODs by email
- Instead, they have an online portal that prospective litigants must use
- Note: On October 19, 2023, the FCHR announced that it will implement a similar online portal
- (no timetable was set, though)
- Note: On October 19, 2023, the FCHR announced that it will implement a similar online portal
- Instead, they have an online portal that prospective litigants must use
- According to regulation, the EEOC will use your FCHR filing date as your EEOC filing date (ie, the filing dates will be the same)
- 29 CFR §1641.5(d) {persuasive authority}
- 29 CFR §1691.5(c) {persuasive authority}
- 29 CFR §1691.6(d) {persuasive authority}
- also see §2E 2023 Workshare Agreement
- If you file your COD within 300 days of the adverse employment act then the EEOC will consider your charge to be “dual filed”
- This is a crucial distinction
- it’ll preserve your right to file a federal lawsuit; and
- it'll provide you protections under ADA/ADEA/Title VII/etc.
- This is a crucial distinction
1.1 | Protected Characteristics (ie, ‘Charged Bases’)
In short, you are covered (ie, you have an age; a skin color; a disability status; and so on). However, not every part of you is covered (eg, you're not protected from ‘height’ discrimination in Florida; etc.).
Nevertheless, things that are not specifically covered may still fall under a covered basis. For example, Florida’s statutes do not cover discrimination on transgender status. Yet, the circumstances surrounding such a charge may fit the fact pattern of sex discrimination – which is covered. The following cases establish this particular point:
• Fishbaugh v Brevard County, 200434 TBD.F 002
• Jacome v Victoria’s Secret, 201542 TBD.F 005
• Shepley v Lazy Days RV, 200446 TBD.F 001
This is a very important point. So, keep these pseudo-protections (as well as the explicit protections - from above) in mind.
** additional note: In practice, the FCHR often lumps pregnancy discrimination into sex discrimination; other times it lumps it into disability discrimination. Either way, if you’ve faced pregnancy discrimination then Florida law will cover you.
*** final note: there've been recent pushes to include protections for genetic information (a là GINA – a federal law). However, TBD hasn’t listed it here because Florida legislation has yet to explicitly include it (see FLSenate.gov). Nonetheless, since genetic information is closely tied to nationality/race/sex/etc, you can probably still file a Florida discrimination suit under those bases.
1.2 | Checklist for an FCHR Charge of Discrimination
☑ Dated
☑ Employer Size (eg, 100 employees)
☑ Location of Events (eg, Florida, etc.)
☑ Signed
☑ Verified
1.3 | Disclose the Adverse Employment Action
- Constructive Discharge
- Demotion
- Denied Reasonable Accommodation
- Disparate Terms & Conditions
- Failure to Hire
- Failure to Promote
- Hostile Work Environment
- Retaliation
- Suspension
- Termination
- Unequal Pay
1.4 | Analysis of a Sample FCHR Charge of Discrimination
# | Point | Image/Explanation |
---|---|---|
1 | ✔ On Time | This litigant successfully filed his COD within Florida's 365-day statute of limitation. ![]() 4/10/19 vs 7/1/18 (283 days ≤ 365 days); or - alternatively - 4/10/19 vs 7/31/18 (253 days ≤ 365 days) {§760.11(1) FS} |
2 | ✔ Verified | This litigant successfully signed this COD under penalty of perjury. ![]() The COD explicitly cites §92.525 FS Read this How-To Guide for more [on applying a verified oath without having to pay a notary] Also, refer to 29 CFR §1601.3(a) |
3 | ✔ Dual-Filed | 4/10/19 vs 7/1/18 (283 days ≤ 300 days); or - alternatively - 4/10/19 vs 7/31/18 (253 days ≤ 300 days) {§2E 2023 EEOC-FCHR Workshare Agreement} room for improvement: explicitly state that your COD is dual-filed (and include the days that have elapsed) |
4 | ✔ Charged Bases Checked | ![]() protects against fraudulent defenses (ie, complainant didn't charge us with "sex" discrimination) |
5 | ✔ Employer Size | This COD successfully indicates the size of the employer. ![]() This is important because the FCHR only covers employers that have 15+ employees (see Phase 2: The Law for more). |
6 | ✔ Adverse Action | This COD clearly states the adverse employment action (ie, 'termination'). |
7 | ✔ Contact Info | ![]() ![]() room for improvement: include email addresses reason: most FCHR communications will be via email (plus, emails are great sources of evidence) |
8 | ✔ Continuing Action | ![]() protects against discovery abuses (eg, 'Plaintiff can request those records because the harassment he/she suffered was of a 'continuing nature'') |
9 | ✔ Short & Plain Statement | "Allstate only fires the black employees who fail exams" see Rule 8 Fed. R. Civ. P.; see Rule 12 Fed. R. Civ. P. (persuasive authority) |
10 | ✔ Substantiating Facts | "Complainant failed an actuarial exam. Respondent terminated him because of it. note: substantiating facts are not necessary, but they can help solidify the charge. |
11 | ✔ Brief | ✓ only one page ✓ quick narrative (corroborates the ultimate facts) |
1.5 | TBD’s Recommendations
o Filing late can ruin your case
■ The 365-day window is paramount
■ The 300-day window is crucial
■ The 180-day window is important
(yet vital for litigants residing in certain US States).
o From TBD’s experience, one of the few noble things that the FCHR is empowered to do is check/administer the filing deadline.
• Use the Form (link)
o It’ll save you time
o It’ll save you money (no need to pay a notary public)
■ reason: it includes the legal citation (ie §92.525 FS) for self-verified oaths.
see this How-To Guide
also, refer to 29 CFR §1601.3(a)
• Keep your COD brief
o Only use 1 page
■ Providing too much detail will only aide your civil opponent (ie, the entity that discriminated against you)
• See Rule 8 Fed. R. Civ. P.
• See Rule 12 Fed. R. Civ. P.
■ Providing too much detail can potentially slow down your case
o Provide a short & plain statement
■ Example 1: Company XYZ fired me because I rejected my boss’ sexual/romantic advances
■ Example 2: Company ABC suspended me because I filed an internal discrimination complaint
■ Example 3: Corporation XYZ demoted me due to my age
■ Example 4: Corporation ABC refused to hire me because of my nationality
■ Example 5: Entity XYZ subjected me to a hostile work environment because of my disability
• Consider talking to one of the EEOC’s/FCHR’s employees beforehand
o Some of their Intake personnel will help litigants draft a proper complaint
■ FCHR Phone Number: 850.488.7082
■ EEOC Phone Number: 800.669.4000 | Miami District Office: 305.808.1740
■ Official Manual on EEOC Inquiries
1.6 | TBD’s Commentary
It’s possible that you might feel as though no one will understand what you’ve gone through. However, your story – although unique – will be very similar to many other cases of employment discrimination.
In TBD’s words, different charges of discrimination are like different songs from the same genre of music. They have similar/identical patterns, but their specific facts/lyrics are different.
Suggestion: Read through TBD’s Index of Charges of Discrimination.
• Benefit #1: Morale
o You’ll see that many people have gone through what you’ve gone through
• Benefit #2: Effectiveness
o You’ll better understand how to articulate/litigate your case So, whether you are alone and/or you just feel alone, get ready to get booked up on all of the knowledge/resources that this website has (and others have) to offer.
A key part of your journey will be knowing how to navigate through the FCHR legal process; and you can fortify that knowledge by learning about the next phase (ie, Phase 2: The Law)...